Description of Learning Needs
Table 14 : Comic Strip Utility
Question Item
N F
Percentage What do you
think of using comic
strips as media in
learning writing
English? Very helpful
32 3
9 Helpful
32 28
88 Not helpful enough
32 Not helpful at all
32
Table 14 shows that almost all of the students stated that using comic as learning media is helpful, while the rest of the students stated that it is very
helpful. From the result above, it can be concluded that using comic strips as one of the media in learning writing is helpful for learners.
Table 15
: Students’ Opinion of a Good Material Question
Item N
F Percentage
What do you think about a
good learning material?
Having many pictures and colorful design
32 11
34 Having a lot of
explanation 32
14 44
Having many examples and texts
32 11
34
From Table 15, it shows that the result of the students’ opinion is almost
even. The highest percentage went to having a lot of explanation, while a third of the students thought that a good material should have many pictures
and colorful design. Then, another a third of the students thought that having many examples and texts is one of the good material characters. In conclusion,
a good learning material was a material which has many pictures and colorful design and has many explanation and examples.
Table 16 : Themes
Question Item
N F
Percentage What kind of
theme do you like?
Schools 32
2 6
Daily life 32
11 34
Hobbies 32
14 44
Living things 32
3 9
Popular things 32
5 16
Table 16 shows that almost half of the students chose hobbies as their favorite theme. Then, a third of the students thought that daily life as their
preferable theme. In conclusion, daily life and hobbies were their favorite themes.
4 Learners’ Roles
Learners’ roles identify what the learners want to do when the learning process is running. The result of the needs analysis related to the le
arners’ role is presented in Table 17.
Table 17
: Learners’ Roles Question
Item N
F Percentage
In a teaching and learning
process, students
should….. listen to the teachers’
explanation 32
8 25
note down everything explained by the teacher
32 6
19 be actively participated in
the learning process 32
22 69
learn individually and do the task quietly
32
Table 17 shows that more than half of the students thought that they should actively participate in the learning process. However, none of the
students chose to learn individually and do the task quietly.
Table 18
: Teachers’ Roles Question
Item N
F Percentage
In a teaching and learning process, a
teacher should….. explain the formula
and ask students to work on the exercises
32 11
34 read the texts and
translate it directly together
with the
students 32
walk around the class while
control students’ work and
give comment on the students’ work
32 4
13
guide the students in discussing the texts
32 20
63
From Table 18, it shows that more than half of the students though that the teacher should guide the students to discuss the texts.