Please give comments on your experience in doing peer feedback in writing

65 RAW DATA OF OPEN-ENDED QUESTIONS

26. Please give comments on your experience in doing peer feedback in writing

Respondents Answers 1 They also give me the honest feedback in my writing, and they give it with clearly so I can understand how can I revise my writing. 2 I can revise my draft based on my friends’ feedback. 3 I can know where is my mistakes and I can repair it. 4 I like peer feedback because it can improve my writing skill 5 I think for doing peer feedback in writing is good. But I can’t to explain it. 6 Doing peer feedback to other friend more effective. 7 Doing peer feedback makes me aware of mistakes. 8 Peer feedback make me aware to my mistake. 9 By give comment in doing peer feedback can help me to be more aware when I make an article. It can improve my critical and I can learn from my peer’s critical. 10 - Make our science develop to give comments - We can know our mistakes so we can revise again. 11 I little bit confused to check the grammar because I actually didn’t too aware and didn’t know if it was correct or incorrect. With peer feedback can improve my skill in writing. 12 Doing peer feedback can improve my writing skill and make me aware of making mistakes. 13 From my feedback, I know my mistakes and I can revise my writing based on my feedback. 14 In the paragraph writing class, we often make a peer feedback. it is useful to improve our skill in writing, by giving and receiving the feedback. we can learn and develop our writing skill. 15 Give comment to other friends is helping them to know the mistakes that they do not know before. 16 Peer feedback in writing can improve my skills because I can learn the mistakes from my peer. APPENDIX 5 RAW DATA OF OPEN ENDED QUESTIONS 66 Respondents Answers 17 Give feedback to another friends make me aware of making mistakes when I do my writing. 18 Peer feedback in writing can improve my skill in stating my argument and giving correction. 19 I think we should aware with any mistakes. Doing peer back writing makes me to be good writer. 20 It’s very useful. 21 I can realize that I have many mistakes in writing. so, I’m really need it. 22 I agree with peer feedback because it can improve our writing skills although sometimes I find difficulty when correcting my friend’s assignment. 23 I am happy when I do peer feedback. - I try and learn to give correction to my peer - I know my mistakes in writing by my peer feedback so, it can help me to be better in writing class. 24 When I do peer feedback in writing, I can find my peer’s mistakes, and I can use my peer’s feedback to revise my writing. 25 The feedback checklist helps me to correct my mistakes. 26 I like giving peer feedback to others, but I’m still learning and sometimes I feel doubt with my peer feedback because I don’t have much knowledge about writing. 27 I think peer feedback is important as long as the peer do it in maximum quality, I mean that heshe does it with strong willingness seriously. In my experience, sometimes the peer couldn’t get the mistakes that I made, so I really need the feedback from teacher. 28 It helps me a lot in improving my writing skill and critical reading. 29 Well I can correct the wrong grammars from my friend’s story. 30 It is better to apply this kind of activity in writing class. it is very helpful 31 It is helpful to improve my draft. 32 I enjoy doing peer feedback. I can learn from my friends’ mistakes. 33 Sometimes, I feel that I can judge whether I’m doing it right or wrong. 67 Respondents Answers 34 Doing peer feedback in writing is very useful. I can learn more from my peer’s mistakes and my peer’s comments and suggestions. It helps me being more understand in my grammar or writing skill. However, sometimes I find any difficulties in giving my peer the feedback. sometimes her writing is misunderstanding and else. But it’s okay because we learn together. 35 I sometimes confuse give comments in writing because I have to understand the writing. 36 I ever get peer feedback from my friends, but the revises are uncorrect. So, I more believe get peer feedback from my lecturer. 37 Difficult, because my knowledge about correcting so writing is less. 38 Sometimes, I make feedback up to me. If I am lazy, I can write anything, even not important thing. 39 I get confused when I read my peer’s work. 40 As stated in No. 21-24, depends whether the peers master the subject or not. Sometimes, peers do not know either about the subject then how can they be giving significant and improvement in writing. 41 I am still confused in doing peer feedback. Sometimes, I don’t feel confidence in giving some correction or some comments to my peer. 42 Sometimes I confuse to check the right correction. 43 I found some difficulties when I check my friend’s writing because I have had some problems in writing too. But I always try to give some feedbacks as good as possible to my friend or my partner. 44 It’s rather difficult for me because my peer and I are students and we still learn how to make a good composition. It makes me become doubt to give comments corrections because I don’t know whether it’s correct or incorrect. 45 Sometimes I’m disagree about my friends exercise. I comments what I feel need for add. But, my friend sometimes disagree with me. 46 Sometimes, I feel so confused to give my feedback to my friend because I know I am not expert so I’m worry that I’m wrong when I give himher a comment. 47 - Difficult to analyze the mistakes - I have doubt feeling 48 Sometimes I feel confuse when I give feedback to my friend’s workwriting because I’m not confidence with my grammar. 68 Respondents Answers 49 Sometimes some friends are afraid shy to give the feedback and even some are doing it just for the sake of doing it without checking it first. 27. How should peer feedback be implemented in writing class? Respondents Answers