2.39 0.73 268,695.6 23,369.57 1,147,826.09 42,028.9 Analisis Komparasi Efisiensi Tataniaga Kubis Secara Ekspor dan Lokal (Kasus:Kecamatan Purba, Kabupaten Simalungun)

Lampiran 1. Karakteristik Petani No Sampel Nama Petani Umur Tahun Pendidikan Tahun Jumlah Tanggungan Jiwa Lama Bertani Tahun Luas Lahan yang Ditanami Kubis Ha 1 Simson Munthe 43 16 4 15 1 2 Sudirman Simamora 45 12 3 18 0.7 3 Berlinson Sinaga 52 12 4 24 1 4 Hotman Munthe 48 12 2 21 1 5 Joni Elisabeth Purba 39 16 2 12 0.5 6 Japorman Purba 50 12 2 20 1 7 Janner Purba 40 12 3 17 1 8 Andi Sipayung 53 12 2 26 0.7 9 Hendrikus Saragih 40 12 2 18 0.5 10 Bonasal Purba 60 9 1 34 0.4 11 Juliasman Sinaga 55 12 2 28 0.3 12 Lassarus Saragih 42 12 4 14 0.5 13 Tarmin Sinaga 51 16 1 24 1 14 Marlen Purba 38 12 3 11 0.6 15 Saruli urba 45 12 2 19 1 16 Muliater Sipayung 56 9 2 31 0.7 17 Ganda Pasaribu 38 12 4 10 0.5 18 Daud Situkkir 41 12 3 9 0.5 19 Parlin Sinaga 32 12 3 5 0.3 20 Riwandi Purba 61 6 35 0.6 21 Ronal Situkkir 45 12 2 18 1 22 Bencaraman Siboro 43 12 3 10 1 23 Berlin Purba 56 9 1 28 1 Jumlah 1073 273 55 447 16.8 Rata-Rata 46.65

11.87 2.39

19.43 0.73

Universitas Sumatera Utara Lampiran 2. Karakteristik Pedagang Pengecer No Nama Pedagang Jenis Kelamin Umur Pendidikan Lama Berdagang 1 Linda Purba Perempuan 32 9 5 2 Rospita Sipayung Perempuan 40 9 6 3 Derma Saragih Perempuan 29 12 2 4 Enna Sinaga Perempuan 45 6 8 5 Melda Purba Perempuan 35 12 5 Total 181 48 26 Rata-Rata 36,2 9,6 5,2 Lampiran 3. Biaya Bibit No Sampel Luas Lahan Ha Produksi Per Musim Tanam Kg Jumlah Bibit Batang Harga Bibit Per Batang Rp Total Biaya Bibt Rp Biaya Pembibitan per Kg Produksi RpKg 1 1 40,000 25,000 85 2,125,000 53.13 2 0.7 28,000 17,500 85 1,487,500 53.13 3 1 35,000 22,000 85 1,870,000 53.43 4 1 40,000 25,000 85 2,125,000 53.13 5 0.5 19,000 11,900 85 1,011,500 53.24 6 1 37,000 23,100 85 1,963,500 53.07 7 1 40,000 25,000 85 2,125,000 53.13 8 0.7 28,000 17,500 85 1,487,500 53.13 9 0.5 20,000 12,500 85 1,062,500 53.13 10 0.4 16,000 10,500 85 892,500 55.78 11 0.3 11,000 7,000 85 595,000 54.09 12 0.5 20,000 12,500 85 1,062,500 53.13 13 1 35,000 22,000 85 1,870,000 53.43 14 0.6 23,000 14,500 85 1,232,500 53.59 15 1 35,000 22,000 85 1,870,000 53.43 16 0.7 28,000 17,500 85 1,487,500 53.13 17 0.5 18,000 15,000 85 1,275,000 70.83 18 0.5 18,000 15,000 85 1,275,000 70.83 19 0.3 11,500 7,200 85 612,000 53.22 20 0.6 23,500 14,700 85 1,249,500 53.17 21 1 40,000 25,000 85 2,125,000 53.13 22 1 40,000 25,000 85 2,125,000 53.13 23 1 38,000 24,000 85 2,040,000 53.68 Jumlah

16.8 644000

411400 1955 34969000 1,263.04 Rata- Rata

0.73 28,000.00

17,886.96 85 1,520,391.30 54.91 Universitas Sumatera Utara Lampiran 4. Biaya Pupuk No Sampel Luas Lahan Ha Biaya Penggunaan Pupuk Per Musim Tanam Total Biaya Pupuk Rp Biaya Pupuk per Kg Produksi Rp ZA SS NPK Kompos Unit Kg HargaKg Rp Total Harga Rp Unit Kg HargaKg Rp Total Harga Rp Unit Kg HargaKg Rp Total Harga Rp Unit Kg HargaKg Rp Total Harga Rp 1 1 400 2,500 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 2 0.7 300 2,500 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 3 1 400 2,500 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 4 1 400 2,500 203.75 203.75 203.75 203.75 203.75 203.75 203.75 203.75 203.75 203.75 203.75 203.75 5 0.5 200 2,500 181.58 181.58 181.58 181.58 181.58 181.58 181.58 181.58 181.58 181.58 181.58 181.58 6 1 400 2,500 215.54 215.54 215.54 215.54 215.54 215.54 215.54 215.54 215.54 215.54 215.54 215.54 7 1 400 2,500 181.25 181.25 181.25 181.25 181.25 181.25 181.25 181.25 181.25 181.25 181.25 181.25 8 0.7 300 2,500 209.82 209.82 209.82 209.82 209.82 209.82 209.82 209.82 209.82 209.82 209.82 209.82 9 0.5 200 2,500 157.50 157.50 157.50 157.50 157.50 157.50 157.50 157.50 157.50 157.50 157.50 157.50 10 0.4 150 2,500 150.00 150.00 150.00 150.00 150.00 150.00 150.00 150.00 150.00 150.00 150.00 150.00 11 0.3 75 2,500 122.73 122.73 122.73 122.73 122.73 122.73 122.73 122.73 122.73 122.73 122.73 122.73 12 0.5 200 2,500 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 13 1 350 2,500 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 206.43 14 0.6 225 2,500 195.65 195.65 195.65 195.65 195.65 195.65 195.65 195.65 195.65 195.65 195.65 195.65 15 1 400 2,500 227.86 227.86 227.86 227.86 227.86 227.86 227.86 227.86 227.86 227.86 227.86 227.86 Universitas Sumatera Utara Sambungan Lampiran 4. Biaya Pupuk 16 0.7 300 2,500 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 194.64 17 0.5 200 2,500 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 18 0.5 200 2,500 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 209.72 19 0.3 100 2,500 143.48 143.48 143.48 143.48 143.48 143.48 143.48 143.48 143.48 143.48 143.48 143.48 20 0.6 225 2,500 191.49 191.49 191.49 191.49 191.49 191.49 191.49 191.49 191.49 191.49 191.49 191.49 21 1 400 2,500 173.13 173.13 173.13 173.13 173.13 173.13 173.13 173.13 173.13 173.13 173.13 173.13 22 1 400 2,500 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 188.75 23 1 400 2,500 190.79 190.79 190.79 190.79 190.79 190.79 190.79 190.79 190.79 190.79 190.79 190.79 Total

16.8 6,625

57,500 4,332 4,332 4,332 4,332 4,332 4,332 4,332 4,332 4,332 4,332 4,332 4,332 Rata- Rata

0.73 288.04

2,500.00 188.37 188.37 188.37 188.37 188.37 188.37 188.37 188.37 188.37 188.37 188.37 188.37 Universitas Sumatera Utara Lampiran 5. Biaya Obat-Obatan No Sampel Luas Lahan Ha Biaya Obat-obatan Rp Jumlah Produksi Kg Biaya Obat-Obatan per Kg Produksi Rp 1 1 2,500,000 40,000 62.50 2 0.7 1,750,000 28,000 62.50 3 1 2,000,000 35,000 57.14 4 1 2,000,000 40,000 50.00 5 0.5 1,000,000 19,000 52.63 6 1 2,000,000 37,000 54.05 7 1 2,000,000 40,000 50.00 8 0.7 1,500,000 28,000 53.57 9 0.5 1,000,000 20,000 50.00 10 0.4 750,000 16,000 46.88 11 0.3 500,000 11,000 45.45 12 0.5 1,000,000 20,000 50.00 13 1 2,500,000 35,000 71.43 14 0.6 1,000,000 23,000 43.48 15 1 2,000,000 35,000 57.14 16 0.7 1,500,000 28,000 53.57 17 0.5 1,000,000 18,000 55.56 18 0.5 1,000,000 18,000 55.56 19 0.3 500,000 11,500 43.48 20 0.6 1,500,000 23,500 63.83 21 1 2,000,000 40,000 50.00 22 1 2,000,000 40,000 50.00 23 1 1,750,000 38,000 46.05 Total

16.8 34,750,000

644,000 1,225 Rata-Rata

0.73 1,510,869.57

28,000.00 53.25 Universitas Sumatera Utara Lampiran 6. Biaya Penyusutan NO Samp el Biaya Penyusutan Pralatan Petani Per Musim Tanam Cangkul Garu Mesin Sprayer Pompa Tangan Total Biaya Penyusut an Jumlah Produksi Kg Biaya Penyusutan per Kg Produksi Rp Unit Total Harga Beli Rp Usia Pakai Bulan Penyu sutan Rp Unit Total Harga Beli Rp Usia Pakai Bulan Penyus utan Rp Unit Total Harga Beli Rp Usia Pakai Bulan Penyusutan Rp Unit Total Harga Beli Rp Usia Pakai Bulan Penyus utan Rp 1 5 300,000 12 15,000 3 75,000 12 18750 - - - - 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 90,893 40,000 2.27 2 4 240,000 12 12,000 2 45,000 12 11250 - - - - 1 800,000 72 33,333 56,583 28,000 2.02 3 6 360,000 12 90,000 2 50,000 12 12500 1 2,750,000 60 137,500 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 297,143 35,000 8.49 4 6 360,000 12 18,000 3 75,000 12 18750 - - - - 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 93,893 40,000 2.35 5 4 240,000 12 60,000 2 50,000 12 12500 - - - - 1 800,000 84 28,571 101,071 19,000 5.32 6 5 300,000 12 75,000 3 75,000 12 18750 1 2,500,000 60 125,000 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 275,893 37,000 7.46 7 6 360,000 12 90,000 3 75,000 12 18750 - - - - 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 165,893 40,000 4.15 8 3 180,000 12 45,000 3 70,000 12 17500 - - - - 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 119,643 28,000 4.27 9 3 180,000 12 45,000 2 50,000 12 12500 - - - - 1 800,000 72 33,333 90,833 20,000 4.54 10 3 180,000 12 45,000 2 50,000 12 12500 - - - - 1 800,000 72 33,333 90,833 16,000 5.68 11 3 180,000 12 45,000 1 25,000 12 6250 - - - - - - - - 51,250 11,000 4.66 12 4 240,000 12 60,000 2 55,000 12 13750 - - - - 1 800,000 84 28,571 102,321 20,000 5.12 13 5 300,000 12 75,000 4 100,000 12 25000 - - - - 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 157,143 35,000 4.49 14 4 240,000 12 60,000 3 70,000 12 17500 - - - - 1 800,000 84 28,571 106,071 23,000 4.61 15 6 360,000 12 90,000 3 75,000 12 18750 - - - - 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 165,893 35,000 4.74 16 5 300,000 12 75,000 3 80,000 12 20000 - - - - 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 152,143 28,000 5.43 17 4 240,000 12 60,000 2 50,000 12 12500 - - - - 1 800,000 72 33,333 105,833 18,000 5.88 18 4 240,000 12 60,000 2 50,000 12 12500 - - - - 1 800,000 84 28,571 101,071 18,000 5.62 19 3 180,000 12 45,000 1 25,000 12 6250 - - - - - - - - 51,250 11,500 4.46 20 4 240,000 12 60,000 2 30,000 12 7500 - - - - 1 800,000 72 33,333 100,833 23,500 4.29 21 5 300,000 12 75,000 3 70,000 12 17500 - - - - 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 149,643 40,000 3.74 Universitas Sumatera Utara Sambungan Lampiran 6. Biaya Penyusutan 22 5 300,000 12 75,000 4 90,000 12 22500 1 2,500,000 60 125,000 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 279,643 40,000 6.99 23 6 360,000 12 90,000 3 70,000 12 17500 1 3,000,000 60 150,000 2 1,600,000 84 57,143 314,643 38,000 8.28 Total 103 6,180,000 276 1,365, 000 58 1,405,00 276 351,250 4 10,750,00 240 537,500 33 26,400,000 1,704 966,667 3,220,417 644,000 115 Rata- Rata

4.48 268,695.6

5 12.00 59,347 .83

2.52 61,086.9

6 12.00 15,271.7 4

0.17 467,391.3

10.43 23,369.57

1.43 1,147,826.09

74.09 42,028.9

9 140,018.1 2 28,000.00 4.99 Universitas Sumatera Utara Lampiran 7. Biaya Tenaga Kerja Petani No Sampel Luas Lahan Ha Biaya Tenaga Kerja Untuk Pengolahan Lahan dan Penanaman Rp Biaya Tenaga Kerja Untuk Penyiangan Rp Biaya Tenaga Kerja Untuk Pemupukan Rp Jumlah Biaya Tenaga Kerja Rp Jumlah Produksi Kg Biaya Tenaga Kerja per Kg Produksi RpKg 1 1 1,800,000 240,000 360,000 2,400,000 40,000 60.00 2 0.7 1,200,000 200,000 200,000 1,600,000 28,000 57.14 3 1 1,500,000 250,000 350,000 2,100,000 35,000 60.00 4 1 1,800,000 200,000 360,000 2,360,000 40,000 59.00 5 0.5 900,000 120,000 180,000 1,200,000 19,000 63.16 6 1 1,400,000 300,000 400,000 2,100,000 37,000 56.76 7 1 1,500,000 300,000 360,000 2,160,000 40,000 54.00 8 0.7 1,200,000 220,000 200,000 1,620,000 28,000 57.86 9 0.5 950,000 100,000 180,000 1,230,000 20,000 61.50 10 0.4 450,000 100,000 100,000 650,000 16,000 40.63 11 0.3 400,000 - 100,000 500,000 11,000 45.45 12 0.5 800,000 120,000 200,000 1,120,000 20,000 56.00 13 1 1,800,000 250,000 350,000 2,400,000 35,000 68.57 14 0.6 1,000,000 200,000 200,000 1,400,000 23,000 60.87 15 1 1,600,000 280,000 360,000 2,240,000 35,000 64.00 16 0.7 1,200,000 200,000 250,000 1,650,000 28,000 58.93 17 0.5 900,000 160,000 180,000 1,240,000 18,000 68.89 18 0.5 800,000 150,000 200,000 1,150,000 18,000 63.89 19 0.3 400,000 - 100,000 500,000 11,500 43.48 20 0.6 1,000,000 150,000 200,000 1,350,000 23,500 57.45 21 1 1,600,000 240,000 360,000 2,200,000 40,000 55.00 22 1 1,700,000 250,000 400,000 2,350,000 40,000 58.75 23 1 1,800,000 240,000 350,000 2,390,000 38,000 62.89 Jumlah

16.80 27,700,000