Target Needs The Result of Needs Analysis
Table 10:
Students’ Goals in Learning Reading Skills
Questions Items
N F
Based on your study program,
the purposes of mastering
reading skills are:
a. To understand the references
which are
used during
learning processes 35
29 82.9
b. To understand the supporting
literatures such as journals and English articles
35 30
85.7
c. To be able to read
mathematics terms 35
30 85.7
d. To be able to read
mathematics symbols 35
21 60
e. To be able to read
mathematics symbols 35
15 42.9
f. To be able to read definitions
and theorems 35
22 62.9
g. Others write down.
35
Table 10 presents the purpose of the students in mastering English reading skills. 85.7 of the students believe that the purposes of mastering English
reading skills are to be able to read mathematics terms and to understand the supporting literatures such as journals and English articles. In addition, their
second choice is to understand the references which are used during learning processes. The third purpose is to be able to read definitions and theorems. The
last is to be able to read mathematics symbols.
2 Lacks
Hutchinson and Waters 1987 say that lack is the gap between the knowledge of the learners and objectives they must be achieved. The students’
view about their lacks is shown as follows.
Table 11:
Students’ Gaps in Reading Skills
Questions Items
N F
Following is a list of reading skills.
Make an order from number 1 to 9
based on the skill you have mastered:
a. Can conduct a quick survey
of the text to identify the topic, the main idea, and the
organization of the text previewing.
35
8 23
b. Can look quickly through the
text to get a general idea of what it is about skimming.
35
5 14
c. Can look quickly through a
text in order to locate specific information scanning.
35
6 20
d. Can anticipate what is to
come predicting.
35
5 14
e. Can ask questions and then
read for answers reading actively.
35
11 31
f. Reading to present
35
7 20
g. Can use context as well as
parts of words e.g. prefixes, suffixes and stems to work
out the meaning of unknown words inferring unknown
vocabulary.
35
6 20
h. Can look back over a text and
summarize it reviewing.
35
5 14
i. Understanding mathematics
vocabulary terms
35
11 31
j. Understanding the meaning
of abbreviations related to mathematics terms
35
7 20
k. Understanding mathematics
symbols
35
8 23
l. Understanding implicit
meanings
35
7 20
In order to classify students’ lack regarding their reading skills, the researcher selected the options which were categorized at 10
th
, 11
th
, and 12
th
places. Table 4.5 shows that 31 of the students have mastered the skills of reading actively and understanding mathematics vocabulary terms. Meanwhile,
23 of the students choose the previewing as the skill they already mastered. 14 of the students claim that their lacks are in reviewing, skimming, and
predicting.
Table 12: Lacks in English Book being used by Students Questions
Items N
F
Based on the following items,
give a tick √ to the parts that you
think not really appropriate on
your English book that being
used: a.
Layout 35
11 31.4
b. The appropriateness of the
texts 35
7 20
c. The appropriateness of the
pictures 35
20 57.1
d. The instructions in every
learning activities 35
8 22.9
e. The
availability mathematics
vocabulary terms
35 13
37.1
f. The
availability mathematics symbols
35 3
8.6 g.
Others write down 35
This table shows the lack in English book being used by students. 57.1 of the students claim that the lack of the current book is related to the
appropriateness of the pictures.
Table 13:
Students’ View in Learning Mathematics
Questions Items
N F
Based on your study program, in
what way do you find mathematics
learning process really difficult?
a. Reading mathematics
vocabulary terms 35
14 40
b. Reading mathematics
symbols 35
18 51.4
c. Reading diagrams
35 6
17.1 d.
Others write down 35
7 20
This table explains students’ view when they learn mathematics. 51.4 of them state that it is difficult in reading mathematics symbols. Meanwhile
40 of the students claim that their difficulty is in reading mathematics vocabulary terms.
3 Wants
Wants refer to students’ view about their needs. Hutchinson and Waters 1987 state another important thing to be considered is students’ wants. The
materials should be presented based on students’ preferences. Table 14
: Students’ View in Learning Mathematics
Questions Items
N F
Based on your study program, in
what way do you find mathematics
learning process really fun?
a. Reading mathematics
vocabulary terms 35
24 68.6
b. Reading mathematics
symbols 35
6 17.1
c. Reading diagrams
35 11
31.4 d.
Reading definitions and theorems
35 13
37.1 e.
Others write down 35
1 2.9
Table 14 shows students ’ view in learning mathematics. 68.6 of the
students claim that reading mathematics vocabulary terms is really fun. While 37.1 of them claim reading definitions and theorems are really fun in the
learning process. Table 15: Skills are Needed in Reading Skills
Questions Items
N F
In your opinion, what skills are
needed in order to be able reading
English texts? a.
Can conduct a quick survey of the text to identify the
topic, the main idea, and the organization of the text
previewing. 35
27 77.1
b. Can look quickly through the
text to get a general idea of what it is about skimming.
35 24
68.6
c. Can look quickly through a
text in order to locate specific 35
22 62.9
information scanning. d.
Can anticipate what is to come predicting.
35 18
51.4 e.
Can ask questions and then read for answers reading
actively. 35
17 48.6
f. Reading to present
35 20
57.1 g.
Can use context as well as parts of words e.g. prefixes,
suffixes and stems to work out the meaning of unknown
words inferring unknown vocabulary.
35 17
48.6
h. Can look back over a text and
summarize it reviewing. 35
20 57.1
i. Understanding mathematics
vocabulary terms 35
15 42.9
j. Understanding the meaning
of abbreviations related to mathematics terms
35 17
48.6
k. Understanding mathematics
symbols 35
15 42.9
l. Understanding implicit
meanings 35
26 74.3
Table 15 shows the skills needed in order to learn English reading skills. 77.1 of the students state the skills needed are those which can conduct a quick
survey of the text to identify the topic, the main idea, and the organization of the text previewing. In addition, 74.3 of the students choose understanding
implicit meanings as the skill they need to learn English reading skills. Meanwhile 68.6 students choose skimming as an important skill in learning
English reading skill. The data shows that there are some points which have the result more than 50. That is why not all of the chosen skills will be provided in
the developed materials.