Simple past tense Result of Test

S ampl e Te st Omis sion Addition Misformation Mi se lec ti on Mi sorde ring R esult Double Mar king R egular iza ti on S im ple Additi on R egular iza ti on Ar chi -fo rm Alter na ti ng - for m 9 1 - - - 1P, 1M - 1V - - 1V 2 1HV - - 1P - 1V - - - 10 1 - - - 1M - 1V - - 2Ad 2 1HV - - - - 1V - - 1HV 11 1 - 1V - - - - - - - 2 2HV - - - - 2HV, 3V - - 1HV 12 1 - - - 1P, 1M - 1HV - - 2HV E rror 2 3HV 1V - 1P - 3V - - 1HV 13 1 - - - - 1PP 2HV, 1V - - - 2 1HV - - - - 1V - 1HV - 14 1 - - - 1M, 1P - 1HV - - 2HV Error 2 2HV - - - 1QW, 1V - - 1HV 15 1 1HV - - - - 1QW, 1V - - - Error 2 2HV - - - - 1QW, 2V, 1HV - - 1HV Description: HV = Helping Verb, M = Modal, O = Object, PP = Personal Pronoun, P = Preposition, QW = Question Word, V = Verb. S ampl e Te st Omis sion Addition Misformation Mi se lec ti on Mi sorde ring R esult Double Mar king R egular iza ti on S im ple Additi on R egular iza ti on Ar chi -fo rm Alter na ti ng - for m 16 1 2HV - - - - 1V - - 1Ad, 1HV E rror 2 2HV 2V - 1P - 2V - - 1HV 17 1 1S 1HV - - - 1HV - 1QW - E rror 2 2HV - - - - 2HV , 3V - - 1HV 18 1 1HV - - 1M 1PP 1HV - 1Ad 2HV E rror 2 1V 1V - - - 1QW - 1QW 1O, 1HV 19 1 1H - - - - 2V , 1HV - - 1HV E rror 2 1HV - - - - 1V , 1QW - - 1HV 20 1 - - - 1HV - 2HV, 1V - - 1HV E rror 2 2HV - - - - 2V - 1HV - 21 1 - - - 1P, 1M - 1V - - 1HV 2 1HV - - - - 1QW, 1V - - 1HV 22 1 1HV - - - - 1HV - - 1HV 2 1HV - - - - 2V - 1HV - 23 1 - 1V - - - - - - - 2 1HV - - 1V - 1V - - 1HV Description: A = Adverb, HV = Helping Verb, M = Modal, O = Object, PP = Personal Pronoun, P = Preposition, QW = Question Word, S = Subject, V = Verb. S ampl e Te st Omis sion Addition Misformation Mi se lec ti on Mi sorde ring R esult Double Mar king R egular iza ti on S im ple Additi on R egular iza ti on Ar chi -fo rm Alter na ti ng - for m 24 1 - - - - - 1HV - - 1HV 2 1HV - - - - 2V, 1HV, 1QW - - - 25 1 2HV - - - - 1V - - 1HV E rror 2 2HV - - - - 1QW, 2V - - 1HV 26 1 1V - - 1HV 1PP 2HV - - - E rror 2 2HV - - - - 2HV, 2V - - 1HV 27 1 1HV - - - - 1HV, 1V - - 1HV E rror 2 2HV - - - - 1QW, 2V - - HV 28 1 1HV 1V - - 1PP 1HV - - 1Ad 2 1HV - - 1P - 1V - - 1HV 29 1 2HV - - 1HV - 2V - - 1HV E rror 2 2HV - - - - 2HV, 2V - - 1HV 30 1 2HV - - - - 1V - - 1HV E rror 2 2HV - - - - 1V - - 1HV 31 1 - - - 1P, 1M - - - - 1Ad 2 2HV - - 1P - 2HV, 4V - - 1HV Description: Ad = Adverb, HV = Helping Verb, M = Modal, PP = Personal Pronoun, P = Preposition, QW = Question Word, V = Verb. S ampl e Te st Omis sion Addition Misformation Mi se lec ti on Mi sorde ring R esult Double Mar king R egular iza ti on S im ple A ddit ion R egular iza ti on Ar chi -fo rm Alter na ti ng -for m 32 1 - - - 1HV 1PP 1HV - - - E rror 2 2HV - - 1P - 2HV , 3V - - 1HV 33 1 - 1V - - - - - - - 2 - - - - - - - - - 34 1 - - - 1M - - - - 1HV 2 2HV - - 1P 2HV 3V - - 1HV 35 1 - - - 1M - 1V - - 2Ad E rror 2 2HV - - 1P - 2HV 3V - - 1HV 36 1 1HV - - - - 1V - - 1HV E rror 2 2HV - - - - 1QW 2V - - 1HV 37 1 1HV 1HV - - - 1V - - 1HV 2 1HV - - - - 1QW 1V - 1QW 1O, 1HV Description: Ad = Adverb, HV = Helping Verb, M = Modal, P = Preposition, PP = Personal Pronoun, QW = Question Word, V = Verb Based on the table above, there are 21 students of 37 students or in percentage 56.7 of all the students who made errors in making wh-question in simple past tense.

d. Simple future tense

Table 4.5 The Distributions of the Students’ Incorrect answer in Simple Future Tense S ampl e Te st Omis sion Addition Misformation Mi se lec ti on Mi sorde ring R esult Double Mar king R egular iza ti on S im ple A ddit ion R egular iza ti on Ar chi -fo rm Alter na ti ng -for m 1 1 - - - - - - - - 1S 2 - - - 1RP - 1V - - 1HV 2 1 1O - - - - - - - 1S 2 - - - 1RP - 1V - - 1HV 3 1 1O - - - - 1QW - - 1S 2 - - - 1RP - - - - 1HV 4 1 - - - - - 1QW - - 2HV 1S E rror 2 - - - 1RP - - - - 2HV 5 1 1O - - - - 1QW - - 1S 2 - - - - - - - - 1HV 6 1 1P, 1O, 1HV - - - - 1QW - - 1S 2 - 1HV - - - 1HV - 1QW - 7 1 1P, 1HV - - - - 2QW - - - 2 - - - 2HV - 3HV - - 2HV Description: HV = Helping Verb, O = Object, P = Preposition, QW = Question Word, RP = Relative Pronoun, S = Subject, V = Verb. S ampl e Te st Omis sion Addition Misformation Mi se lec ti on Mi sorde ring R esult Double Mar king R egular iza ti on S im ple A ddit ion R egular iza ti on Ar chi -fo rm Alter na ti ng -for m 8 1 1HV - - - - 1QW - - 1S 2 - - - - - - - - 1HV 9 1 1HV - - - - 1QW 1V - - 2 - - - - - - - - 1HV 10 1 1HV - - - - 1QW 1V - 1HV, 1S 2 - - - - - - - - 1HV 11 1 - - - - - - - 1QW 1HV, 1S 2 - - - - - - - - - 12 1 - - - - - 1QW - - 1HV, 1S 2 - - - 1HV - 1HV - - - 13 1 - - - - - - - - 1HV, 1S 2 - - - 1RP - 1V - - 1HV 14 1 1O - - - - - - - 1HV, 1S 2 - - - - - - - - - 15 1 1O - - - - - - - 1S 2 - - - 1HV - 1HV - - 1HV Description: HV = Helping Verb, O = Object, P = Preposition, QW = Question Word, S = Subject, V = Verb. S ampl e Te st Omis sion Addition Misformation Mi se lec ti on Mi sorde ring R esult Double Mar king R egular iza ti on S im ple A ddit ion R egular iza ti on Ar chi -fo rm Alter na ti ng -for m 16 1 1O - - - - 1QW - - 1HV, 1S 2 - - - - - - - 1QW - 17 1 1V - - - - 1QW - - - 2 - - - - - 1HV, 1V - - - 18 1 1O - - - - 1QW - - 1S 2 - - - - 1PP 1HV, 1V - - 1HV 19 1 1O - - - - 1QW - - 1S 2 - - - - - - - - - 20 1 1O - - - - - - - 1S 2 - - - 1RP - 1PP - - 1HV 21 1 1O - - - - - - - 1S 2 - - - - - - - - - 22 1 1O - - - - 1QW - - 1HV, 1S 2 - - - 1RP - - - - 1HV 23 1 - - - - - 1QW - - 1S 2 - - - - - - - - - Description: HV = Helping Verb, O = Object, PP = Personal Pronoun, QW = Question Word, R = Relative Pronoun, S = Subject, V = Verb.