The Tim es: For a Change
The Tim es: For a Change
THE TIMES' PRICE CUT FROM 45p to 30p in July 1993 shook the United Kingdom quality newspaper industry. Rupert Murdoch's News International, whose Times newspaper had a circulation of 360,000, had declared war on
the other quality daily newspapers: the Daily Telegraph (circulation 1,017,000), the Guardian (403,000), the Independent (336,000) and the
Financial Times (288,000). It was not the first time News International (Ml) had started a price war. NI, which owns five of the UK's national papers as
well as many others around the world, had already cut the price of its Sun tabloid newspaper from 25 to 20p. The move had consolidated the Sun's position as market leader, pushing its circulation up from 3.43 million to
4.10 million, within a year. Sales of the Sun's chief competitor, the Daily
Chapter Preview: Tlie Times • 679
Mirror, dropped from 2.67 million to 2.50 million over the same period. People have very strong relationships to their daily newspapers and, given the papers' different political leanings, many in the industry thought the quality papers were not price sensitive. NI clearly thought otherwise. 'Obviously we would like to push it [The Times] to the same (circulation] level as the Telegraph and beyond,' said Gus Fischer, chief executive of NI,
Very soon NI was proved right. By April 1994 The Times' circulation had grown to 478,000 while most of the others had gone down: Telegraph, 999,000; Guardian, 397,000; said Independent 271,000. The specialist and expensive (65p) Financial Times was not affected at all; the leftofcentre Guardian and rightofcentre Telegraph saw sales drop a little, while the Independent, which had increased its price to 50p in response to The Times' price cut, had a 20 per cent sales drop. After an initial shortterm sales decline, the midmarket dailies, Today, Daily Express and Daily Mail, were unaffected by the low prices of the Sun and The Times.
Refore the priee cut, the quality newspapers had competed in other ways. Throughout the 1980s their strategy was to improve the product by adding sections. According to one senior executive, 'The daily market has
been contracting every year. We have been almost excessively focused on sales promotion to encourage trial from rival papers. We hoped that the added value products would keep our readers more loyal.' But to the consumers, more did not mean better. Most of the brand extensions (supple ments) were created to attract advertising revenue; not to keep readers' loyalty. By offering advertisers 'high definition, high quality' targets, publishers had taken their eyes off the circulation figures. Wooing new
advertisers did not keep customers happy. Increased pagination meant paper bills went up and consumers were frustrated at not being able to 'get
through the paper' at one sitting. Loyalty was declining before The Times'
680 • Chapter 16 Pricing Considerations and Approaches
price cut, but its true magnitude only became known later. Analysis of Taylor Kelson AGB's Mediaspan panel showed that newspapers lose and gain at least 20 per eent of their 'loyal readers' each year. This switching excludes casual readers, since loyal readers are defined as those 'almost always reading' a paper. Following the price cut, The Times' users showed much lower loyalty than usual. The paper boosted its regular readership by two thirds, but onethird of the regular 1993 readership was lost by 1994. Further analysis in May 1994 using RSGB's Conversion Model showed that about half the readers of all quality newspapers were 'safe' (entrenched or average loyalty), while the rest of the readers were Vulnerable' (shallow or convertible). The study also showed that The Times had fewer entrenched readers than the other quality newspapers.
After The Times' price cut, the quality newspapers had fought hard to keep their customers. The Telegraph offered free books to people who collected tokens printed in the paper and the cashstrapped Independent ran a promotion competition with the prize equal to the winner's income tax bill. But the Independent's lost circulation hurt and cash was running out. When newspapers lose circulation, two forms of income drop: income from the cover price, and advertising revenue. The fewer the readers, the lower the advertising rates. The Independent was the newest of the quality news papers and also financially the weakest. Founded by the brilliant entrepre neur and editor, Andreas Whittam Smith, the Independent's biggest shareholders were Italy's La Repubhlicu and Spain's El Pais newspapers, neither very rich. After initially taking the market by storm, the paper overextended itself on an expensive launch of the Independent an Sunday and a failed attempt to take over the Observer, another Sunday paper.
If it was to survive the circulation war, the Independent needed more money. Surprisingly for a newspaper facing a price war, there were three prospective new partners. One was Tony O'Reilly, Irish chairman of Heinz and owner of Independent Newspapers; another was Conrad Black, Canadian proprietor of the Telegraph; the third was Newspaper Publishing, publishers of the Daily Mirror. After reassuring the Independent about editorial independence, Newspaper Publishing bought the Independent and the battle continued.
After holding the price up for eight months after The Times' first price cut, on 22 June 1994 Conrad Black cut the Telegraph's price from 48p to match The Times at 30p. The Times quickly responded with a cut to 2()p two
days later, determined to hang on to the 150,000 extra buyers from its first price cut. On that day the Independent's Whittam Smith moved his editorial to the front page accusing The Times of predator;' pricing. 'Two rightwing ideo logues, Rupert Murdoch and Conrad Black, have set about to destroy the
quality newspaper market,' he thundered. NI was thought to be losing £45 million from its earlier price cutting of The Times and the Sun. Lost profits at The Times were thought to be about £17 million. The extra cut to 20p would cost £12 million more a year if retailers were to maintain their current 17p a copy, and with printing costs running at t3p a copy. Shareholders were also unimpressed by the Telegraph's action: £800 million was wiped off the share
value of the newspaper as a whole and it lost £200 million in value. The City was particularly angered since Conrad Black's Hollinger Group had sold 12.5
million shares, raising £73 million, barely a month before the price cut. In August 1994 the Independent caved in and reduced its price. Sales by then were as follows: Telegraph, 1,010,000; The Times, 510,000; Guardian, 400.000; and Independent 280,000. After market testing prices of 45p and 40p. the Independent exceeded City expectations and cut its price to 30p.
Introduction
NI stressed the newspaper would not remain at 30p indefinitely a move that would cost the newspaper £14 million per year in lost revenue. 'It is felt that the premium quality that the Independent achieves will, in the longer term, warrant a premium cover price,' said its editorial. 1
Parts
» Book Principles Of Marketin Pleased
» I'hrce considerations underlying the
» The Information Technology Boom
» • False Wants and Too Much Materialism
» There is good reason to search a 2.4
» Levi's Strategic Marketing and Planning
» Analysing the Current Easiness Portfolio
» Conflict Between Departments
» Marketing Strategies for Competitive Advantage
» Principal actors in the company's
» • Persistence of Cultural Values
» McDonald's; Breaking into the South African Market
» Analysis of International Market Opportunity Deciding Whether or Not to Go Abroad
» Understanding the Global Environment
» Procter & Gamble: Going Global in Cosmetics
» Sheba: The Pet's St Valentines Day Pedro Quclhas Brito, Universidade do Porto, Portugal
» Individual Differences in Innovativcncss
» Influence of Product Characteristics on Rate of Adoption
» Selling Business Jets: The Ultimate Executive Toy
» • Systems Buying and Selling
» • Strong Influences on Government Buyers
» TABI.EI GOVERNMENT CODES OF PRACTICE IN VARIOUS COUNTRIES
» Qantas: Taking Off in Tomorrow's Market
» • Defining the Problem and Research Objectives
» CLOSEDEND QUESTIONS NAME DESCRIPTION
» Estimating Total Market Demand
» Estimating Actual Sales and Market Shares
» TimeSeries Analysis technology.
» Segmenting International Markets
» • Selecting Market, Segments
» 2 VOLUME BRAND SHARES (%) BRAND SHARE CoffeeMate total: 55.5
» 7 CONSUMPTION BY HOUSEHOLD SIZE (PER PERSON/WEEK)
» Preview Case Gastrol: Liquid Engineering
» Determine the Competitors'Positions One way of defining competitors is to look at
» Communicating and Delivering the Chosen Position
» The Need for Customer Retention
» The Ultimate Test: Customer Profitability
» 1 POTENTIAL PRODUCT FIELDS FOR AN EXPANSION OP THE UNCLE BEN'S BRAND
» 2 VARIETIES OF UNCLE BEN'S FEINSCHMECKER SAUCE
» Federal Express: Losing a Packet in Europe
» Close or Distant Competitors
» • Expanding the Total Market
» • The Customer Service Department
» What Governs NewProduct Success?
» Lufthansa: Listening lo Customers
» Managing Productivity CU _ C7 ^ •
» Mattel: Getting it Right is No Child's Play
» Internal Factors Affecting Pricing Decisions
» • BreakEven Analysis and Target Profit Pricing
» 1 CAR OWNERSHIP ACROSS THE EUROPEAN UNION
» Mobile Phones: Even More Mobile Customers
» Stena Sealink versus Le Shuttle, Eurostar and the Rest
» Preview Case British Home Stores
» • Selecting the Message Source
» Setting the Total Promotion Budget
» Factors in Setting the Promotion Mix
» Integrated Marketing Communications
» Setting the Advertising Budget
» • Selecting Advertising Media
» Standardization or Differentiation
» Media Planning, Buying and Costs
» IBM Restructures the Sales Force
» • Other Sales Force Strategy and Structure Issues
» 5 per cent sales elite apart from the rest is 'an astounding 60 per cent [are] just there for the
» Britcraft Jetprop: Whose Sale is it Anyhow? 1
» 1 COMMERCIAL SUCCESS OF THE JETPROP AIRCRAFT, 1992 NUMBER OF CONTINENT
» 1 PANEUROPEAN CONSUMER GROUPS
» Analyzing Customer Service Needs
» Defining the Channel Objectives and Constraints
» Identifying Major Alternatives
» Designing International Distribution Channels
» Evaluating and Controlling Channel Members
» • Building Channel Partnerships
» The Growth of Direct Marketing
» Customer Databases arid Direct Marketing
» DirectResponse Television Marketing
» Online Marketing and Electronic Commerce
» Germany, the UK and other countries in Europe 1997 to SI.64 billion or 7.5 per cent of global
» • Creating an Electronic Storefront
» • Participating in Forums, Newsgroups and IVcb Communities
» • The Promise and Challenges of Online Marketing
» Roberto Alvarez del Blanco and Jeff Rapaport*
Show more