87
D. Section 2
1. What are the strengths and weaknesses of the designed materials? The strengths are:
The weaknesses are:
2. In a general way, what are your criticism, comments, and suggestions about the overall materials?
__THANK YOU VERY MUCH__
Appendix F
The Result of the Questionnaires from the Evaluators
88
EVALUATION QUESTIONNAIRE A. Respondents’ Identities
Sex Educational
Background Occupation
Teaching Experience
Female S1
Teacher 8 years
Male S1
Lecturer 15 years
B. Section 1
No Participants’ Opinions
Degrees of Agreement 1
SD 2
D 3
A 4
SA Objectives
1. The designed materials met the students’
need. 2
2. The designed materials match the learning
objectives. 2
3. The
indicators have
already been
formulated properly. 1
1
Method and Technique 4.
The method is applicable for the designed materials.
2 5.
The method and technique used enable students enhance their speaking skill.
2 6.
The techniques
are suitable
for Communicative
Language Teaching
CLT method. 2
Learning Activities 7.
The materials in each unit are well- designed and relevant to the topics.
2 8.
The students are able to complete the activities in each unit.
2 9.
The activities area able to facilitate the students to speak English properly.
2 10.
The time allocation is suitable for each unit.
2 11.
The designed materials are able to help the students to enhance the students’
speaking skill. 2
12. The learning activities have been varied.
2 13.
The instructions are already clear. 1
1
89
Materials 14.
The language is appropriateeasy to understand for the students.
2 15.
The vocabulary chosen is accordance with the students’ level.
2 16.
The layoutappearance is interesting. 2
17. The designed materials of the teacher’s
book are already complete. 1
1 18.
The explanation of each section of the teacher’s book is already clear.
1 1
Notes:
SD 1 : Strongly disagree
D 2 : Disagree
A 3 : Agree
SA 4 : Strongly agree
C. Section 2
1. What are the strengths and weaknesses of the designed materials? The strengths are:
The activities are varied and encourage students to practice speaking. The layout is well-arranged and interesting.
The weaknesses are: Natural language usage and incomplete instruction.
2. In a general way, what are your criticism, comments, and suggestions about the overall materials?
Generally, the materials are well-developed.
Appendix G
Questionnaire for the Students on the Implemented Materials
Kategori