Development pengembangan Hasil Penelitian 1. Tahap analysis analisis
7 7
Sangat t idak layak
Tidak Layak
Layak Sangat Layak
3 V a
l i
d a
s i
g u
r u
ma t
a p
e l
a j
a r
a nt
e r
h a
d a
p b
u k
u s
a k
u p
r o
s e
s b
u b
u t
V a
l i
d a
t o
r d
a r
i p
r a
k t
i s
i p
e mb
e l
a j
a r
a n
a d
a l
a h
g u
r u t
e k
n i
k p
e me
s i
n a
n y
a n
g t e
r d
i r
i d
a r
i d
u a
g u
r u
ma t
a p
e l
a j
a r
a n
t e
k n
o l
o g
i me
k a
n i
k y
a i
t u
S l
a me
t Wi
d o
d o
,S .
P d
d a
n S
u h
a r
s o
n o
,A md
. V
a l
i d
a s
i t
e r
k a
i t
a s
p e
k k
e l
a y
a k
a n
i s
i ,
k e
l a
y a
k a
n k
e b
a h
a s
a a
n ,
d a
n k
e l
a y
a k
a n
p e
n y
a j
i a
n d
a r
i b
u k
u s
a k
u y
a n
g d
i k
e mb
a n
g a
k a
n d
e n
g a
n p
e n
g i
s i
a n
a n
g k
e t
b e
r s
k a
l a
1 -
4 .S
e c
a r
a r
i n
g k
a s
, r
e k
a p
i t
u l
a s
i n
i l
a i
d i
s a
j i
k a
n d
a l
a m
t a
b e
l s
e b
a g
a i
b e
r i
k u
t :
T a
b e
l 1
4 .
Ha s
i l
v a
l i
d a
s i
b u
k u
s a
k u
o l
e h
g u
r u
ma t
a p
e l
a j
a r
a n
No A
s p
e k
K e
l a
y a
k a
n Gu
r u
I Gu
r u
I I
R a
t a
- r
a t
a J
u ml
a h
Ni l
a i
R a
t a
- r
a t
a J
u ml
a h
Ni l
a i
R a
t a
- r
a t
a 1
K e
l a
y a
k a
n i
s i
28 4
27 3,
8 3,
9 2
K e
l a
y a
k a
n k
e b
a h
a s
a a
n 5
8 3,
8 5
8 3,
8 3,
8 3
K e
l a
y a
k a
n p
e n
y a
j i
a n
4 3
3, 9
4 3
3, 9
3, 9
4 T
o t
a l
1 29
1 1
, 7
1 29
1 1
, 5
1 1
, 6
5 R
a t
a -
r a
t a
Ni l
a i
3,8
6 K
a t
e g
o r
i
Sangat layak
S u
mb e
r :
Da t
a p
e n
e l
i t
i a
n p
e n
g e
mb a
n g
a n
y a
n g
d i
o l
a h
l a
mp i
r a
n :
1 6
1 -
1 6
3 .
B e
r d
a s
a r
k a
n t
a b
e l
d i
k e
t a
h u
i b
a h
wa r
a t
a -
r a
t a
s k
o r
X 3,
8 d
e n
g a
n p e
r s
e n
t a
s e 9
5 ,
t e
r l
e t
a k
p a
d a
r e
n t
a n
g X ≥ 3 d
e n
g a
n b
e r
a r
t i
me d
i a
y a
n g
d i
k e
mb a
n g
k a
n me
n d
a p
a t
n i
l a
i d
e n
g a
n k
a t
e g
o r
i
“ sangat layak”.
Ha s
i l
v a
l i
d a
s i
o l
e h
a h
l i
ma t
e r
i me
n u
n j
u k
k a
n b
a h
wa b
u k
u s
a k
u d e
n g
a n
t e
ma “
me n
g e
n a
l p
r o
s e
s b
u b
u t
” y
a n
g
100 75
62,5 50
85
7 8
d i
k e
mb a
n g
k a
n b
e r
d a
s a
r k
a n
p e
n i
l a
i a
n d
a r
i a
s p
e k
k e
l a
y a
k a
n i
s i
, k
e b
a h
a s
a a
n ,
d a
n p
e n
y a
j i
a n
, l
a y
a k
u n
t u
k d
i u
j i
c o
b a
k a
n s
e s
u a
i k
o me
n t
a r
d a
n s
a r
a n
.
Sangat t idak layak
Tidak Layak
Layak Sangat Layak
R e
k a
p i
t u
l a
s ih
a s
i lv
a l
i d
a s
ik e
s e
l u
r u
h a
n g u
r u
ma t
a p
e l
a j
a r
a n
j i
k a d
i s
a j
i k
a nd
a l
a m
d i
a g
r a
m b
a t
a n
ga d
a l
a h
s e
b a
g a
i b
e r
i k
u t
:
3. 7
3. 7
5 3.
8 3.
8 5
3. 9
3. 9
5 4
I S
I K
E B
A HA
S A
A N
P E
NY A
J I
A N
R A
T A
- R
A T
A 4
3. 8
3. 9
3. 8
3. 8
3. 9
3. 9
3. 8
3. 9
3. 8
GURU I
GURU I
I R
A T
A -
R A
T A
Ga mb
a r
2. Di
a g
r a
m b
a t
a n
g r
e k
a p
i t
u l
a s
i v
a l
i d
a s
i s
e l
u r
u n
g u
r u
ma p
e l
. d
. R e
v i
s i
d a
nP e
mb u
a t
a n
B u
k u
S a
k u
Dr a
f f
I I
R e
v i
s i
a t
a u
p e
n y
u n
t i
n g
a n
b e
r f
u n
g s
i u
n t
u k
me mi
n i
ma l
i s
i r
k e
s a
l a
h a
n -
k e
s a
l a
h a
n d
a n
me n
j a
d i
k a
n b
u k
u s
a k
u l
a y
a k
d i
g u
n a
k a
n .
R e
v i
s i
d i
l a
k u
k a
n s
e t
e l
a h
p r
o d
u k
a wa
l b
u k
u s a
k u
d r
a f
f I
d i
v a
l i
d a
s i
o l
e h
a h
l i
ma t
e r
i d
a n
a h
l i
me d
i a
.B e
r i
k u
t i
n i
a d
a l
a h
h a
l -
h a
l y
a n
g p
e r
l u
d i
r e
v i
s i
b e
r d
a s
a r
k a
n s
a r
a n
d a
r i
p a
r a
a h
l i
:
100 75
62,5 50
95
7 9
1 P
e r
b a
i k
a n
t e
r h
a d
a p
p e
n y
u s
u n
a n
ma t
e r
i a
l a
t p
o t
o n
g .
Da l
a m
p e
n y
u s
u n
a n
a wa
l a
l a
t p
o t
o n
g ma
s u
k d
a l
a m
ma t
e r
i p
e r
l e
n g
k a
p a
n me
s i
n b
u b
u t
. B
e r
d a
s a
r k
a n
s a
r a
n d
a r
i a
h l
i ma
t e
r i
a l
a t
p o
t o
n g
ma s
u k
d a
l a
m ma
t e
r i
p o
k o
k s
e n
d i
r i
s e
h i
n g
a a
l e
b i
h j
e l
a s
d a
n mu
d a
h d
i p
a h
a mi
.
Ga mb
a r3.
Ma t
e r
i a
l a
t p
o t
o n
g s
e b
e l
u m
r e
v i
s i
8 Ga
mb a
r4 .
Ma t
e r
i a
l a
t p
o t
o n
g s
e t
e l
a hr
e v
i s
i 2 P
e r
b a
i k
a n
p a
d a
e j
a a
n b
a h
a s
a u
n t
u k
l e
b i
h me
mp e
r mu
d a
h me
ma h
a mi
k a
l i
ma t
. B
e r
d a
s a
r k
a n s
a r
a n
d a
r i
a h
l i
ma t
e r
i u
n t
u k
me r
u b
a h
e j
a a
n b
a h
a s
a d
a r
i p
e n
g e
r t
i a
n y
a n
g l
u a
s me
n j
a d
i l
e b
i h
s p
e s
i f
i k
s e
h i
n g
g a
mu d
a h
d i
p a
h a
mi ma
k s
u d
n y
a o
l e
h s
i s
wa .
P e
r b
a i
k a
n e
j a
a n
b a
h a
s a
d a
p a
t d
i l
i h
a t
p a
d a
g a
mb a
r 5
, 6
, 7
, d
a n
8 s
e b
a g
a i
b e
r i
k u
t :
8 1
Ga mb
a r5
.E j
a a
n b
a h
a s
a s
e b
e l
u m r
e v
i s
i
Ga mb
a r6
.E j
a a
n b
a h
a s
a s
e t
e l
a h r
e v
i s
i
8 2
Ga mb
a r7
.C o
n t
o h
s o
a l
s e
b e
l u
m r e
v i
s i
Ga mb
a r8
.C o
n t
o h
s o
a l
s e
t e
l a
h r e
v i
s i
8 3
3 P e
r b
a i
k a
n d i
l a
k u
k a
n p a
d a
u k
u r
a n
g a
mb a
r y
a n
g b
e r
h u
b u
n g
a n
d e
n g
a n
t a
b e
l .Ga
mb a
r a
wa l
me n
u n
j u
k k
a n
b a
h wa
t a
b e
l t
e r
l a
l u
k e
c i
l ,
s e
h i
n g
g a
k u
r a
n g
j e
l a
s a
p a
y a
n g
d i
ma k
s u
d k
a n
.B e
r d
a s
a r
k a
n s
a r
a n
d a
r ia
h l
i ma
t e
r i
p e
r l
u a
d a
n y
a p e
mb e
s a
r a
n p
a d
a g
a mb
a r
, s
e h
i n
g g
a l
e b
i h
j e
l a
s d
a n
mu d
a h
u n
t u
k d
i l
i h
a t
.P e
r b
a i
k a
n g
a mb
a r
d a
p a
t d
i l
i h
a t
p a
d a
g a
mb a
r 1
0, 1
1 ,
1 2,
d a
n 1
3 s
e b
a g
a i
b e
r i
k u
t :
Ga mb
a r9
.T a
b e
l k
e c
e p
a t
a n
spindle s
e b
e l
u m r
e v
i s
i
8 4
Ga mb
a r1
0.T a
b e
l k
e c
e p
a t
a n
spindle s
e t
e l
a h r
e v
i s
i
Ga mb
a r1
1 .T
a b
e l
t u
a s
p e
n g
a t
u rk
e c
e p
a t
a n
spindle s
e b
e l
u m r
e v
i s
i
8 5
Ga mb
a r1
2.T a
b e
l t
u a
s p
e n
g a
t u
r k
e c
e p
a t
a n
spindle s
e s
u d
a h r
e v
i s
i 4
P e
r b
a i
k a
n d i
l a
k u
k a
n p a
d a
u k
u r
a n
i l
u s
t r
a s
i g
a mb
a r
p r
o s
e s
p e
mb u
b u
t a
n .Ga
mb a
r a
wa l
me n
u n
j u
k k
a n
b a
h wa
g a
mb a
r t
e r
l a
l u
k e
c i
l ,
s e
h i
n g
g a
k u
r a
n g
j e
l a
s .B
e r
d a
s a
r k
a n
s a
r a
n d
a r
i a
h l
i ma
t e
r i
p e
r l
u a
d a
n y
p e
mb e
s a
r a
n p
a d
a g
a mb
a r
, s
e h
i n
g g
a l
e b
i h
j e
l a
s .
P e
r b
a i
k a
n d
a p
a t
d i
l i
h a
t p
a d
a g
a mb
a r
1 3
d a
n 1
4 ,
s e
b a
g a
i b
e r
i k
u t
:
8 6
Ga mb
a r1
3.I l
u s
t r
a s
i p
r o
s e
s b
u b
u ts
e b
e l
u m r
e v
i s
i
Ga mb
a r1
4 .I
l u
s t
r a
s i
p r
o s
e s
b u
b u
ts e
s u
d a
h r e
v i
s i
8 7
5 P
e r
u b
a h
a n
p a
d a
t a
b e
l a
n g
k a
k e
t a
b e
l n
o mo
g r
a m.T
a b
e l
a wa
l me
n u
n j
u k
k a
n b
a h
wa t
a b
e l
t e
r s
e b
u t
d a
l a
m b e
n t
u k
t a
b e
l a
n g
k a
d e
n g
a n
h u
r u
f y
a n
g t
i d
a k
j e
l a
s .B
e r
d a
s a
r k
a n
s a
r a
n d
a r
i a
h l
i ma
t e
r i
p e
r l
u a
d a
n y
a p
e r
u b
a h
a n
d a
r i
t a
b e
l a
n g
k a
k e
t a
b e
l n
o mo
g r
a m
s e
h i
n g
g a
s i
s wa
l e
b i
h mu
d a
h me
ma h
i ma
k s
u d
n y
a .P
e r
b a
i k
a n
d a
p a
t d
i l
i h
a t
p a
d a
g a
mb a
r 1
5 ,1
6 ,1
7 ,
d a
n 1
8 ,
s e
b a
g a
i b
e r
i k
u t
:
Ga mb
a r1
5 .T
a b
e l
k e
c e
p a
t a
n p
o t
o n
g s
e b
e l
u m r
e v
i s
i
8 8
Ga mb
a r1
6 .T
a b
e l
k e
c e
p a
t a
n p
o t
o n
g s
e s
u d
a h r
e v
i s
i
Ga mb
a r1
7 .T
a b
e l
k e
c e
p a
t a
n ma
k a
n s
e b
e l
u m r
e v
i s
i
8 9
Ga mb
a r1
8 .T
a b
e l
k e
c e
p a
t a
n ma
k a
n s
e b
e l
u m r
e v
i s
i 6
P e
r u
b a
h a
n p
a d
a t
a b
e ld
i me
n s
i u
l i
r .T
a b
e l
a wa
l me
n u
n j
u k
k a
n b
a h
wa h
u r
u f
y a
n g
t e
r t
e r
a p
a d
a t
a b
e l
k u
r a
n g
j e
l a
s ,
s e
h i
n g
g a
s u
l i
t u
n t
u k
d i
b a
c a
.B e
r d
a s
a r
k a
n s
a r
a n
d a
r i
a h
l i
ma t
e r
it a
b e
l d
i b
u a
t s
e n
d i
r i
d i
k e
t i
k u
l a
n g
a g
a r
l e
b i
h j
e l
a sp
e r
l u
a d
a n
y a
p e
r u
b a
h a
n d
a r
i t
a b
e l
s e
h i
n g
g a
s i
s wa
l e
b i
h mu
d a
h me
ma h
i ma
k s
u d
n y
a .P
e r
b a
i k
a n
d a
p a
t d
i l
i h
a t
p a
d a
g a
mb a
r 1
9 ,20,21
, d
a n
22 s
e b
a g
a i
b e
r i
k u
t :
9 Ga
mb a
r1 9
.T a
b e
l d
i me
n s
i u
l i
r me
t r
i s
s e
b e
l u
m r e
v i
s i
Ga mb
a r20.T
a b
e l
d i
me n
s i
u l
i r
me t
r i
s s
e s
u d
a h r
e v
i s
i
9 1
Ga mb
a r21
.T a
b e
l d
i me
n s
i u
l i
r wh
i t
h wo
r t
h s
e b
e l
u m r
e v
i s
i
Ga mb
a r22.T
a b
e l
d i
me n
s i
u l
i r
wh i
t h
wo r
t h
s e
s u
d a
h r e
v i
s i
9 2