The Appropriateness of the Presentation of Unit 1
17. The developed materials are in accordance with the steps of scientific approach-based learning as required by Curriculum 2013.
4 18. The developed materials are in accordance with the characteristics
of Communicative Language Learning. 4
19. The developed materials are begun with guided tasks and gradually move to the free production tasks.
3 20. The materials are systematically graded from the easy tasks to more
difficult tasks. 4
21. The developed materials encourage learners to actively interact in English with classmates, teachers, and other people.
4 22. The developed materials encourage students to get involved in
spoken communicative events on their own initiative. 4
23. The developed materials encourage students to get involved in written communicative events on their own initiative.
4 24. The developed materials promote learners to be responsible with
their own learning so that they become autonomous learners. 4
25. The developed materials encourage learners to have self-reflection to identity their achievements and lacks during their learning.
3 26. Each unit of the developed materials has the learning objective
stated. 4
27. Each unit of the developed materials has a summary part that provides the summary of the learning materials presented in the unit
4 28. Each unit of the developed materials has homework part.
4 29. Each unit of the developed materials has
intermezzo Did You
Know
part that is relevant to the topic. 4
Mean F 3.8
The Appropriateness of the Graphic of Unit 1
30. The developed materials are printed on ISO-standardized size papers A4,A5,B5
4 31. The layout of the developed materials is proportional.
3 32. The illustrations and graphic designs in the developed materials are
relevant to the topic and the contents. 4
33. The illustrations and graphic designs in the developed materials are aesthetic and fuctional.
4 34. The illustrations and graphic designs in the developed materials
help to clarify the presentation of the materials. 4
35. The developed materials use the appropriate variation of fonts. 4
36. The developed materials use the right number of variation
bold, italic, underline, capitalization
. 4
37. The overall design of the developed materials is visually interesting.
4
Mean F 3.9
B. The Results of the Expert Judgment of Unit 2
The Appropriateness of the Content of Unit 2 NO
Items Score
1. The developed materials are in accordance with the core
competences stated in Curriculum 2013 for grade XI students of vocational high school.
4 2.
The developed materials are in accordance with the basic competences stated in Curriculum 2013 for grade XI students of
vocational high school. 4
3. The developed materials meet the course grid.
4 4.
The topics of the units of the developed materials are relevant with the grade XI students of Beauty Skin Care study programme’s daily
life. 4
5. The developed materials involve the explanation of the structure of a
text of a particular genre. 4
6. The developed materials involve the explanation of social functions
of a text of a particular genre. 4
7. The developed materials involve the explanation of linguistic
features of a text of a particular genre. 4
8. The developed materials involve vocabulary learning tasks which are
relevant with the requirement of the curriculum. 3
9. The developed materials involve pronunciation learning tasks which
are relevant with the requirement of the curriculum. 3
10. The developed materials involve learning activities which guide students to develop their communicative competence in spoken
language. 3
11. The developed materials involve learning activities which guide students to develop their communicative competence in written
language. 3
Mean F 3.6
The Appropriateness of the Language of Unit 2 NO
Items Score
12. The language of explanations and instructions in the developed materials is in accordance with the grade XI students of beauty skin
care programmes’s cognitive development. 4
13. The language used in the developed materials is unambiguous and understandable by the students.
4 14. The language used in the developed materials is grammatically
correct. 3
15. The language used in the developed materials is cohesive and coherent.
4 16. The developed materials consistently used one variation of English.
4
Mean F 3.8
The Appropriateness of the Presentation of Unit 2
17. The developed materials are in accordance with the steps of scientific approach-based learning as required by Curriculum 2013.
4 18. The developed materials are in accordance with the characteristics
of Communicative Language Learning. 4
19. The developed materials are begun with guided tasks and gradually move to the free production tasks.
3 20. The materials are systematically graded from the easy tasks to more
difficult tasks. 4
21. The developed materials encourage learners to actively interact in English with classmates, teachers, and other people.
3 22. The developed materials encourage students to get involved in
spoken communicative events on their own initiative. 3
23. The developed materials encourage students to get involved in written communicative events on their own initiative.
3 24. The developed materials promote learners to be responsible with
their own learning so that they become autonomous learners. 3
25. The developed materials encourage learners to have self-reflection to identity their achievements and lacks during their learning.
3 26. Each unit of the developed materials has the learning objective
stated. 4
27. Each unit of the developed materials has a summary part that provides the summary of the learning materials presented in the unit
4 28. Each unit of the developed materials has homework part.
4 29. Each unit of the developed materials has
intermezzo Did You
Know
part that is relevant to the topic. 4
Mean F 3.5
The Appropriateness of the Graphic of Unit 2
30. The developed materials are printed on ISO-standardized size papers A4,A5,B5
4 31. The layout of the developed materials is proportional.
4 32. The illustrations and graphic designs in the developed materials are
relevant to the topic and the contents. 4
33. The illustrations and graphic designs in the developed materials are aesthetic and fuctional.
4 34. The illustrations and graphic designs in the developed materials
help to clarify the presentation of the materials. 4
35. The developed materials use the appropriate variation of fonts. 4
36. The developed materials use the right number of variation
bold, italic, underline, capitalization
. 4
37. The overall design of the developed materials is visually interesting. 4
Mean F 4
