46 47.4 Coral Reef, Destructive Fishing, and Fishery Sustainability

using explosive, muroami and over fishing UNDPFAO Report 1982 in Soekarno 1989: 68. Data in 1989 shows that the average percent cover of coral colonies along the upper reef slope of the islands of Rajuni Besar, Rajuni Kecil, Tinanja, Tarupa Kecil, Latondu Kecil and Jinato ranged from 40 to 59 Table 30 Soekarno 1989. The latest investigation in 2000 showed that the average hard coral cover is 50 Table 31. After four years of community assistance, the external assistance in these islands has not been certain if the ecological condition of coral reefs was improved LP3M 2002b. Table 30 Reef substrates cover and number of coral genera at Taka Bonerate Atoll in 1989 Percent cover Substrate Jinato Island Latondu Timur Island Latondu Barat Island Rajuni Kecil Island Rajuni Besar Island Tinanja Island Tarupa Island Average Sand 9.5 12 19.5 11 15 8.5 22 13.9 Rubble 20 12 20.5 6 14.5 6 22.5 14.5 Turf algae 35 26.5 30 35 39.5 51.5 38 36.5 Coral 51.5 59 53 45 40

37.5 46 47.4

Soft coral 37 37.75 31 19 28.5 62 54.5 38.5 Seagrass algae 12 0.5 35.5 34 39.5 2 19 20.3 Number coral genera 24 20 23 34 29 34 28 - Source: Soekarno 1989. Table 31 Average percent of hard coral cover at Taka Bonerate MNP in 2000 Percent of hard coral cover Location From Manta tows From detailed survey B. Tinanja 24 47.5 Ampalasa Island 14 48.0 Latondu Kecil Island 23 48.0 Rajuni Kecil Island 33 58.1 Tinabo Besar Island 20 48.1 Balanda Reef 26 54.8 Bongko Reef 22 47.2 Bubbe Reef 24 48.9 Gama Reef 23 50.4 Gantarang Reef No data 49.4 Kumai Reef 23 51.6 Rajuni Reef 37 54.9 Teros Reef 31 48.5 T. Tumbor 27 45.4 Average 25 50.1 Source: Coremap-ACIL 2000. Barrang Caddi and Kapoposang Coral reef condition in Barrang Caddi Island was only 25 in good condition, while in Kapoposang is 70 Table 32. Table 32 Coral reef condition in South Sulawesi in 2003 City District Area of coral reef Ha Percent Damaged Percent Good Makassar 1 1.80 45.56 54.44 ƒ Barrang Caddi Island 0.5 75 25 Pangkep 2 210,455.03 54 46 ƒ Kapoposang Island 500 30 70 Selayar 3 No data Source: DKP South Sulawesi 2003. Note: 1 Barrang Caddi Island lies in Makassar City. 2 Kapoposang Island lies in Pangkep District. 3 Taka Bonerate atoll lies in Selayar District. The living coral cover in Barrang Caddi is in between 10-50. Western and Southern part of Barrang Caddi had good coral reef condition, with living coral between 70-80 Table 33. On the other hand, the coral cover in Kapoposang TMP were in the range of 40-60 and of 60 Table 34. Table 33 Coral cover in Barrang Caddi Island in 2005 Percent cover Location Depth m Hard coral Soft coral Sponge Rubble Sand Dead coral East 2 - 17 10 - - - 70 20 South 2 - 17 50 10 5 25 10 15 West 2 - 20 40 10 - - 60 20 North 2 - 15 30 - - 20 60 - Source: PSTK Unhas 2005. Table 34 Type of marine habitat in Kapoposang TMP Type of habitat Area Ha Percent Shallow turbid waters max. 5m 150.55 0.30 Deep sedimentary areas 5m; sedimentary areas 60 25.65 0.05 Coral formation, deep waters 5m; coral cover 60 4,701.00 9.40 Coral formation, shallow waters 5m; coral cover 60 45.62 0.09 Spare coral formation; coral cover 40-60 5,372.58 10.75 Dense reef flat; hard substratum 60 3.40 0.007 Scattered reef flat; hard substratum 40-60 671.58 1.34 Shallow sedimentary areas; sand and rubble 60 2,686.29 5.37 Seagrass beds 184.90 0.37 Beaches 84.00 0.17 Deep sea 36,074.43 72.15 Total 50,000.00 100.00 Source: MREP Part A, BCEOM South Sulawesi Thematic Map, Pulau Kapoposang, Sheet Sangkarang 01, 1996, scale 1:50,000, in Ministry of Forestry 1998.

5.2 State of Destructive Fishing