The Understanding of Total Physical Response
Regarding to those definitions above, it can be seen that “learning English at least a brief explanation of the theory, goal, and instruction format is
most helpful in setting students at ease and quickly involving them in action.”
36
This is like children when they learn their first language before they learn to speak children do a lot of listening to their parents and they hear a lot of commands from
adult. They respond the command with action, for example: “give mommy a big kiss”, “look at the bird in the sky”, etc. And also they do a lot of physical
activities in learning their first language, such as reaching, moving and grabbing. Based on the statement above Total Physical Response emphasizes on
developing comprehension skills before the learner is taught to speak.
37
It means that if comprehension skills from the students are built, it will be easy to learn
how to speak in English because they have the skill and the knowledge about language. This is in line with Asher in Richards and Rodgers’ book, who differ
several different comprehension-based language teaching proposal, which share the belief that:
38
a Comprehension abilities precede productive skills in learning a language; b The teaching of speaking should be delayed until comprehension skills are
established; c Skills acquired through listening transfer to other skills;
d Teaching should emphasize meaning rather than form; e Teaching should minimize learner stress.
The focus of Total Physical Response is when students learn English they will have no stress or teacher will reduce or minimize the learner stress with the
physical movement or action when teaching learning process in the classroom. Total Physical Response is mainly used with imperatives and this method
only appropriate for children or young learner. However, Total Physical Response
36
Robert W. Blair, Innovative Approaches to Language Teaching, Rowley: Newbury House Publishers, inc., 1982, p. 54
37
Jack C. Richards, and Theodore S. Rodgers, Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching: A Description and Analysis, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1986, p. 87.
38
Jack C. Richards, and Theodore S. Rodgers, Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching: A Description and Analysis, … pp. 87-88.
is not only suitable for children or young learner but this also can be used to teach any foreign language for adult learner.
39
It depends on selection of kinds of imperative sentence that teaches by the teacher. The only advantage young learner
have is acquiring a near-native pronunciation.
40
It means that Total Physical Response can be used for adult learner but with different material and with the
more time than children to improve the acquiring in imperative. Because this method has many physical movements, this method seems to
be done in a class with a big class without chairs and tables. But this is not always true. The usual classroom in Indonesia is with chairs and table because of those
chairs and tables even other things in the classroom can be used as a tool to learn imperative. Example: Move the chairs near the white board. The teacher can
make the classroom like laboratory where the things around the class can be useful in learning process.
In Indonesia, most of the schools have students in the classroom are more than 40 students and according to Asher this is not an ideal one. According to
Asher in Setiyadi book teaching English as a foreign language, about the ideal group size in the class. He suggested, “that the ideal group size is 20 to 25
students. If there are more than 40 students in one class, the class can be divided into several smaller groups.”
41
With smaller groups every student will have the same opportunity to respond the command from teacher. One kind of activities
that can be done with the small group is the teacher utter commands and then model by responding with appropriate action. Each group listens to the commands
from the teacher and responds with actions to the spoken commands.
42
In sum up, Total Physical Response is the method that involves physical activity in the classroom to help student understanding easily the sentence in
imperative before they learn how to speak English in the small class if the class have a lot of students.
39
Bambang Setiyadi, Teaching English as A Foreign Language, Yogyakarta: Graha Ilmu, 2006, p. 126.
40
Bambang Setiyadi, Teaching English as A Foreign Language, … p. 126.
41
Bambang Setiyadi, Teaching English as A Foreign Language, … p. 127.
42
Bambang Setiyadi, Teaching English as A Foreign Language, … p. 127.