Action and Observation Report of Cycle 1
characteristics of a narrative text. After reviewing the material on the previous meeting, she then asked about the homework. Some of them did not do the
homework. They confessed that they were still confused in differentiating the regular and irregular verbs. Together with the students, the researcher discussed
the answer. She explained the differences of regular and irregular verbs and also gave some examples. After explaining to the students, she asked them to search
other examples from the text they had read. Several students mentioned the verbs from the text. After that, they were given a list of irregular verbs including the
meaning of them to enrich their vocabulary and linguistic knowledge. Next, the researcher asked the students to sit with their groups. The group
seat was arranged from group 1 to 7, because it makes her more easily monitor them. She allocated the group seat. She ordered them based on the instruction she
gave. They with their groups discussed and started to create the product. In this session, they had to make a draft then consult it with her. After that, they had to
develop their drafts to be a full narrative text. The researcher moved around to monitor students’ work. To avoid the member of group that did not participate in
developing the project, she asked the students to report to her if there were students that did not work. The class then became very noisy. Some groups were
left behind because of the member that did not work cooperatively. Meanwhile, some other groups seemed really enjoy the process.
The researcher asked the students to sit with their groups. To make it easier, the seat of the group was arranged from group the first group to the last
group. The students with their group discussed and created the project planned in the preceding meeting. To avoid the members that did not work and contribute,
the students were asked to write down the members that did not participate in
developing the project. Some groups were left behind in developing their product. Some others seemed really enjoyed producing the project.
FN 7-16042015
The next activities were giving feedback on the other groups’ writing and revising their own group writing. Each group had to exchange their work to the
other groups. The feedback given could be about the content, the organization of the text, the vocabulary used, the sentence structure and mechanics such as
spelling and punctuation. When they finished correcting other groups’ writing, they returned the writing to the group. Because the lesson time was only 40
minutes, the project was continued in the next meeting. The students’ writing then was submitted to the researcher to receive feedback from her.
After concluding the material learned, the researcher asked students to do Task 8 as homework. She ended the lesson by greeting them and saying goodbye.
3 Meeting 3
As usual, the researcher began the class by greeting the students, saying prayer and checking students’ attendances whether there were students who were
absent or not. Then she started the lesson by reviewing the previous material learned. Most of them responded to the questions given by her by looking at the
notes they took. She then reminded them that they had homework that was completing a text with given words in the box. She asked them to write down the
answer in the board. Some students said that they had not finished their homework and a few of them confessed that they did not know the meaning of some words
because they were too lazy to open the dictionary.
Before going to the next task, the students were given some pictures and asked to compose a sentence for each picture. The sentence should be relevant to
the picture given. There were four different pictures. The time given for them to produce 4 sentences was 10 minutes. After that, the researcher asked them one by
one to read the sentences they made. She also gave oral feedback directly to them and encouraged them to be not afraid to make mistakes.
The lesson was continued by giving the students a task to arrange the paragraphs into a good text and also highlight the verbs used in the text. They
were given 15 minutes to finish this task. In completing the task, they worked with their groups. This activity was aimed to deepen their knowledge about the
text organization of a narrative text .
Instead of searching the meaning of words in the dictionary they borrowed from the library, they kept asking the researcher, the
teacher and the second collaborator of some words they did not familiar with. The students and the researcher then discussed the answer together. The researcher
then reminded the students about the organization of a narrative text. The students were asked to be quiet and asked to pay attention to the researcher’s
explanation. The researcher moved around the class to monitor students’ work. Some of them kept asking to her the definition of some words on the text. They
chose to ask the researcher instead of searching it in the dictionary. After they finished doing the task, they and the researcher started to discuss the answer.
FN 8-18042015
Next, the students revised and finished their work after they were given feedback from the researcher. They were allowed to decorate their writing. It took
much time than that of the time allocated for finishing the project. They were finishing their project until the class ended. Soon after all the students were done
with their project, the researcher concluded the lesson, reminded the students about the principles of a narrative text, the grammatical rules, the text
organization of narrative, the content, and also the punctuations. She closed the lesson by saying prayer and goodbye.