209
APPENDIX G Results of Expert Judgement Questionnaire of the First
Draft of Materials
I. The appropriateness of the content of the first draft of materials
A. The relevancy of the content
No Items Mean
Category 1
The materials are appropriate to the learning goals
3.00 Neither
agree nor disagree
2 The materials developed are appropriate
to the needs of hotel reception staff 2.50
Disagree
B. The depth of the content
No Items Mean
Category 3
The materials explore many texts which are relevant to the learners’ daily lives
2.75 Neither
agree nor disagree
4 The materials elaborate the input texts in
details 3.00
Neither agree nor
disagree
5 The materials generally provide clear
explanations about linguistic features and meaning structures
2.50 Disagree
C. The accuracy of the content
No Items Mean
Category 6
The materials provide the explanation about the expressions used in asking for
and giving help , asking for and giving
direction , asking for and giving
suggestions in hotel and hospitality
contexts 2.50
Disagree
7 The texts given in the materials help the
learners to understand the parts of hotel reservation form, map,
and tourism brochure
3.00 Neither
agree nor disagree
8 The materials provide the explanation
about how to use modal verb, preposition of place,
and simple present tense correctly
3.00 Neither
agree nor disagree
9 The inputs texts, tables, pictures,
supplements, etc of the materials were taken from sources relevant to the topic
2.50 Disagree
10 The inputs texts, tables, pictures, supplements, etc of the materials were
2.50 Disagree
taken from the updated sources and relevant to the topic
II. The appropriateness of the language of the first draft of materials
A. The appropriateness to the learners’ language development
No Items Mean
Category 1
The language used in the instruction is appropriate to the learners’ cognitive
development 3.00
Neither agree nor
disagree
2 The language used in the explanation is
appropriate to the learners’ cognitive development
4.00 Agree
3 The language used is appropriate to the
learners’ level of language proficiency 3.50
Agree
B. The use of communicative language
No Items Mean
Category 4
The language used is presented clearly and understandable to the learners
4.00 Agree
C. The accuracy of the language
No Items Mean
Category 5
The materials employ the correct and appropriate language use
3.50 Agree
D. The sequencing and the unity of ideas
No Items Mean
Category 6
The materials presented in a unit designtasksentence represent the sequence
of conveying meanings and ideas 3.50
Agree
7 The texts presented in the materials
represent the unity of ideas 3.50
Agree
III. The appropriateness of materials presentation of the first draft of materials
A. The technique of presentation
No Items Mean
Category 1
The materials consists of the introduction, main activities, evaluation, reflection, and
summary sections presented consistently in all units
4.50 Strongly
Agree
2 The tasks are presented equally in every
unit 4.00
Agree 3
This first draft of materials presents the tasks developed based on the principles of
materials development 4.00
Agree
4 The types of activitiestasks are presented
variously 4.50
Strongly Agree
B. Learning presentation
No Items Category
Mean 5
The presentation of tasks in the materials encourages learners’ interactions in
English 4.00
Agree
6 The tasks in the materials encourage the
learners to participate actively in the classroom
4.00 Agree
7 The presentation of the tasks and
materials encourages the learners to be autonomous learners
4.00 Agree
8 The materials encourage the learners to
recognize their achievement as well as the weakness in learning English
3.50 Agree
IV. The appropriateness of layout of the first draft of materials
A. The layout of the content
No Items Mean
Category 1
The placement of the elements of the materials, i.e titles, introductions,
illustrations in the beginning of every unit is consistent
4.50 Strongly
Agree
2 The placement of the elements in every
page follows a consistent pattern 4.00
Agree 3
The structure of the texts in the materials in the materials shows a distinct separation
4.00 Agree
Kategori