Liabilitas pajak tangguhan Deferred tax liabilities

PT XL AXIATA Tbk DAN ENTITAS ANAK AND SUBSIDIARIES Halaman 80 Page CATATAN ATAS LAPORAN KEUANGAN KONSOLIDASIAN INTERIM YANG TIDAK DIAUDIT UNTUK PERIODE TIGA BULAN YANG BERAKHIR 31 MARET 2016 DAN 2015 Dinyatakan dalam jutaan Rupiah, kecuali dinyatakan lain NOTES TO THE UNAUDITED INTERIM CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE THREE-MONTH PERIODS ENDED 31 MARCH 2016 AND 2015 Expressed in millions of Rupiah, unless otherwise stated 28. PERPAJAKAN lanjutan

28. TAXATION continued e. Surat ketetapan pajak lanjutan

e. Tax assessments continued Perseroan lanjutan

The Company continued Tahun pajak 2006 2006 fiscal year Pada bulan September 2008, Perseroan menerima SKPKB atas beberapa obyek pajak penghasilan, PPN dan denda pajak dengan jumlah Rp 157.876. Pada bulan Desember 2008, Perseroan membayar kekurangan pembayaran pajak tersebut. Perseroan membebankan Rp 155.871 dalam laporan laba rugi konsolidasian tahun 2008 dan mengajukan keberatan kepada DJP atas SKP PPh Pasal 23, SKP PPh Pasal 26 dan SKP PPN. In September 2008, the Company received tax assessment letters confirming the underpayment of various income taxes, VAT and tax penalties totalling to Rp 157,876. In December 2008, the Company paid the underpayment of these income taxes. The Company recorded Rp 155,871 in the 2008 consolidated statements of profit or loss, and filed the objection letters to DGT regarding income tax Article 23, Article 26 and VAT. Pada bulan Desember 2009, DJP menolak keberatan Perseroan atas SKP PPh 23 dan menerima sebagian keberatan atas SKP PPh 26 dan PPN. Perseroan mencatat hasil keputusan ini pada laporan laba rugi konsolidasian Perseroan tahun 2010 setelah memperhitungkan saldo klaim restitusi pajak sebesar Rp 1.221. Pada bulan Maret 2010, Perseroan mengajukan permohonan banding ke Pengadilan Pajak atas keputusan keberatan PPh Pasal 26 dan PPN. Pada bulan Oktober 2014, Pengadilan Pajak menolak permohonan banding Perseroan atas obyek PPN. Pada bulan Maret 2015, Pengadilan Pajak menerima seluruh permohonan banding Perseroan atas keputusan keberatan PPh 26 sebesar Rp 104.686. Perseroan telah menerima pengembalian pajak tersebut pada tanggal 5 Juni 2015. In December 2009, DGT rejected the objection over income tax Article 23 and partially accepted the objection over income tax Article 26 and VAT. The Company recorded the results in the 2010 consolidated statements of profit or loss taking into account the restitution claim of Rp 1,221. In March 2010, the Company submitted an appeal to Tax Court in relation to income tax Article 26 and VAT. In October 2014, the Tax Court rejected the appeal in relation to VAT. In March 2015, the Tax Court accepted all the Company’s appeal of income tax Article 26 for an amount of Rp 104,686. The Company has received the tax refund on 5 June 2015. Pada bulan Januari 2016, DJP membatalkan Surat Tagihan Pajak STP atas PPh pasal 26 untuk periode Januari – Desember 2006 sejumlah Rp 11.999. Perseroan telah menerima pengembalian pajak tersebut pada bulan Maret 2016. In January 2016, DGT cancelled Tax Collection Letters STP for income tax Article 26 for January – December 2006 period totalling Rp 11,999. Company has received the tax refund in March 2016. PT XL AXIATA Tbk DAN ENTITAS ANAK AND SUBSIDIARIES Halaman 81 Page CATATAN ATAS LAPORAN KEUANGAN KONSOLIDASIAN INTERIM YANG TIDAK DIAUDIT UNTUK PERIODE TIGA BULAN YANG BERAKHIR 31 MARET 2016 DAN 2015 Dinyatakan dalam jutaan Rupiah, kecuali dinyatakan lain NOTES TO THE UNAUDITED INTERIM CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE THREE-MONTH PERIODS ENDED 31 MARCH 2016 AND 2015 Expressed in millions of Rupiah, unless otherwise stated 28. PERPAJAKAN lanjutan

28. TAXATION continued e. Surat ketetapan pajak lanjutan

e. Tax assessments continued Perseroan lanjutan

The Company continued Tahun pajak 2007 2007 fiscal year Pada tahun 2009, Perseroan menerima SKPKB atas PPN, PPh Badan, PPh Pasal 23 dan PPh Pasal 26 dimana Perseroan mengajukan permohonan keberatan kepada DJP atas SKPKB tersebut. Perseroan melunasi seluruh SKPKB sejumlah Rp 103.447 dan mencatat jumlah tersebut pada laporan laba rugi konsolidasian Perseroan tahun 2009. In 2009, the Company received tax assessment letters confirming underpayment of VAT, corporate income tax, income tax Article 23 and income tax Article 26 of which the Company filed objection letters to DGT against these tax assessments. The Company paid underpayment of these income tax amounted to Rp 103,447 and recorded it in the 2009 consolidated statements of profit or loss. Pada tahun 2010, DJP menolak keberatan Perseroan atas SKPKB PPh Pasal 26 dan menambah kurang bayar PPh Pasal 26 menjadi sebesar Rp 80.145. Perseroan telah membayar jumlah tersebut dan membebankan dalam laporan laba rugi konsolidasian tahun 2010. Perseroan kemudian mengajukan banding kepada Pengadilan Pajak atas keputusan keberatan PPh Pasal 26, dan di bulan Maret 2013, Pengadilan Pajak menerima sebagian permohonan banding Perseroan sebesar Rp 17.325. Pada bulan Juni 2013, DJP mengajukan permohonan peninjauan kembali ke MA atas keputusan Pengadilan Pajak tersebut. Sampai dengan tanggal penyelesaian laporan keuangan konsolidasian interim, MA belum memberikan putusan atas permohonan peninjauan kembali yang diajukan DJP tersebut. In 2010, DGT rejected the objection regarding income tax Article 26 and increased the underpayment of income tax Article 26 to become Rp 80,145. The Company paid the underpayment and charged it to the 2010 consolidated statements of profit or loss. The Company then submitted an appeal letter to the Tax Court for the objection result of income taxes Article 26, and in March 2013, the Tax Court par tially accepted the Company’s appeal for an amount of Rp 17,325. In June 2013, DGT has submitted a judicial review to the SC regarding the Tax Court’s decision. Up to the date of the completion of these interim consolidated financial statements, the SC has has not issued its decision on the judicial review requested by DGT. Pada tahun 2010, DJP juga menolak keberatan Perseroan atas SKPKB PPh Badan, PPh Pasal 23 dan PPN. Perseroan kemudian mengajukan permohonan banding ke Pengadilan Pajak atas keputusan keberatan tersebut. Pada bulan Juli 2013, Pengadilan Pajak menolak permohonan banding Perseroan atas keputusan keberatan PPN sebesar Rp 30.371. Perseroan setuju dengan keputusan tersebut. Pada tanggal yang sama, Pengadilan Pajak mengabulkan sebagian permohonan banding Perseroan terkait dengan kurang bayar PPh 23 sebesar Rp 1.898 dari keseluruhan jumlah klaim Perseroan sebesar Rp 2.037. Perseroan setuju dengan keputusan tersebut. Pada bulan Januari 2014, DJP mengajukan permohonan peninjauan kembali ke MA atas keputusan Pengadilan Pajak untuk PPh 23. Sampai dengan tanggal penyelesaian laporan keuangan konsolidasian interim, MA belum memberikan putusan atas permohonan peninjauan kembali yang diajukan DJP tersebut. In 2010, DGT also rejected the Company’s objection regarding corporate income tax, income tax Article 23 and VAT. The Company then submitted an appeal letter to the Tax Court regarding the objection results. In July 2013, the Tax Court rejected the Company’s appeal relating to VAT amounting to Rp 30,371. The Company agreed with the decision. The Tax Court also partially accepted the Company’s appeal relating to underpayment of income tax Article 23 amounting to Rp 1,898 of the total amount claimed by the Company of Rp 2,037. The Company agreed with the decision. In January 2014, DGT submitted a judicial review to the SC regarding the Tax Court’s decision on Article 23. Up to the date of the completion of these interim consolidated financial statements, the SC has has not issued its decision on the judicial review requested by DGT.